AI Technology Gone Wrong
Someone Used AI to Clone Our Roofing Company
Here's how we found out, and how to check if it's happened to you

Amy and Josh Vandevender, owners of St. Louis Roofing & Siding in Kirkwood, Mo.
Our company spent over 20 years building our reputation: an A+ with the BBB, Owens Corning Preferred status, drone inspections by an FAA-licensed remote pilot, FORTIFIED certified, and years of building a brand with loyal customers. This summer, someone copied it all with AI.
Before 2024, we were a small, old-school company. Our estimates were on paper; we hadn't automated our systems or implemented a CRM, and we rarely asked customers for Google reviews, or even understood why it mattered. We had an old, out-of-date website and relied on word-of-mouth advertising. While long overdue, we finally hired a marketing company to improve our website and search engine optimization (SEO). What we discovered was completely by accident.
We didn't know much about SEO, so during this process, I consulted with ChatGPT for advice on planning the site and improving our Google rankings. Its guidance led us to ExteriorSTL.com, a fictitious company that used our customer testimonials, which, according to ChatGPT, may be affecting our rankings by confusing Google's algorithms. Even more alarming, the site not only reproduced our customer testimonials almost word for word, but claimed to offer drone inspections, hold an A+ BBB rating, and have Owens Corning Preferred status. When I looked up their address, it listed 123 Main Street in St. Louis—an address that doesn't exist. There was an immediate sick feeling in the pit of our stomachs; we felt like we had just been robbed. We decided to run a sting operation: we asked a neighbor to request a roof inspection, then confronted the person who showed up. On camera, he admitted, "I'm not a roofer," but blamed his partner for creating the false website.
With the help of our local news station, we investigated further. I searched the BBB and Secretary of State registries and checked with our local Owens Corning representative, who had never heard of the company. The good news is the site is down now. Here's how you can check whether it's happening to you, and what we did once we found it.
How to Check in 15 Minutes
- Search for your testimonials. Put a sentence from one of your reviews in quotation marks and search for it.
- Search for your credentials and verify who comes up.
- Ask AI assistants about yourself. ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Gemini read the whole web. That's how we found our clone.
What We Did Once We Found It
1. We found out who kept the site online. You don't need to know who runs a site to report it. You need the companies that keep it online, and three free lookups told us:
- ICANN Lookup: the registrar and its abuse email address
- Whois: the nameservers, which often show the DNS or hosting company
- A hosting checker: the IP address and hosting company. If it shows Cloudflare, Cloudflare is usually just sitting in front of the real host.
2. We gathered evidence: side-by-side screenshots, the exact URLs with copied material, archived copies showing our content was published first, and proof that the testimonials came from our customers.
3. We reported it everywhere at once:
- Registrar: deceptive domain use and impersonation
- Hosting company: copied content and copyright infringement
- Cloudflare, if it shows up: it passes reports on to the real host
- Google: request removal of the copied content through its legal removal portal
- Your state attorney general: a business that fakes credentials to get onto homeowners' roofs is a consumer protection issue. We filed with the Missouri AG.
- Local news: First Alert 4 (KMOV) helped with the investigation. They brought in a cybersecurity expert and called the number listed on the site.
We reported everything in our story on Aug. 13 and it was offline by Aug.19.
Protect what a Copycat Steals
- Keep your manufacturer directory, BBB, and Google Business Profile listings complete and up to date.
- Ask customers for specific reviews that mention a neighborhood or project type. They're harder to pass off as someone else's.
- Keep your website current, including your business location.
Tell Homeowners to Check
Before anyone climbs on their roof, remind homeowners to confirm three things: the company is registered with the state, the company is fully insured, and the address is real.
AI makes your reputation cheap to copy. Spend 15 minutes each quarter searching for yourself. If you find a copy, don't wait to take action-report immediately.
Looking for a reprint of this article?
From high-res PDFs to custom plaques, order your copy today!








