search
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube instagram Spotify Podcasts Apple Podcasts Spotify Podcasts Apple Podcasts
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
  • NEWS
  • TOPICS
    • Cool Roofing
    • Event News
    • Latinos in Roofing
    • Low Slope
    • Legal
    • Metal
    • Project Profiles
    • Roofing Supply Pro
    • Roofing Safety
    • Steep Slope
    • Sustainable Roofing
    • Technology
  • EXCLUSIVES
    • Best of Success
    • Contractor Profile
    • IRE Show
    • Roofing Contractor of the Year
    • Top 100
    • Young Guns
    • State of the Industry
    • Century Club
  • MULTIMEDIA
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
    • Interactive Spotlights
    • Roofing Quizzes
    • IRE Videos
    • Webinars
    • Photo Galleries
  • PRODUCTS
    • New Products
    • Featured Products
  • COLUMNS
    • Editor's Note
    • Exit Planning
    • Legally Speaking
    • Safety Advice
    • Technical Details
    • Guest Column
  • EVENTS
    • International Roofing Expo
    • Webinars
    • Best of Success Conference
    • Industry Events
  • DIRECTORY
    • Associations
    • Distributors
    • Manufacturer/Supplier
    • Business Services
    • Get Listed
  • MORE
    • Roofing Contractor eNews
    • Techos y Más Advisory Board
    • RC Store
    • Roofing Supply Pro
    • Custom Content & Marketing Services
    • Market Research
    • Sponsor Insights
    • Company Spotlights
    • Classifieds
      • Auctions
      • Business For Sale
      • Business Opportunities
      • Equipment For Sale
      • Positions Available
      • Products
      • Safety
      • Software
      • Services
      • Training
    • Contact Us
  • EMAGAZINE
    • eMagazine
    • Advertise
      • Media Kit
      • Editorial Calendar
      • Contact
    • Archive Issues
  • SIGN UP!
Columns

Smart Business: Avoid The Seniority Trap

By Jim Olsztynski
December 1, 2005
Knowledge is recognizing a good poker hand. Wisdom is knowing when to hold it and when to fold it.

Turn to the help wanted ads in almost any newspaper, and you'll see listing after listing asking for "three years experience ... minimum five years experience ... experienced person wanted." This holds true for blue-collar and white-collar positions alike.

The underlying mentality is hard to argue with. Most employers looking to fill a vacancy don't have the time or wherewithal to train a novice to handle the job, particularly for skilled trade positions. If you need a roofer, you can't very well take people off the street who have never installed a shingle in their lives and expect them to do so in a productive and safe manner without months if not years of at least on-the-job training.

It's right to value experience. Those of us with decades of experience - and I count myself among them - almost always know more tricks of the trade than people who haven't been around as long. We also are likely to have more in the way of wisdom, as opposed to knowledge.

Knowledge means having a grasp of myriad details applicable to any given job. A lot of whiz kids coming right out of college or trade school can have almost as much knowledge as veterans when it comes to working with the tools of the trade. However, few have the knack for identifying which details are most important in any given situation. That's where wisdom comes in, and it usually correlates with experience. Knowledge is recognizing a good poker hand. Wisdom is knowing when to hold it and when to fold it.

The Value of Veteran Employees

From the time we learned to walk and talk we've been taught that respect for elders is one of our culture's most enduring values. We owe a debt of gratitude to those who came before us. Despite what you are about to read, do not think for a moment that I will belittle the value of experience.

All this being said, be careful about going overboard in deference to veteran employees. I feel almost like a traitor to my demographic group in saying so, but intellectual honesty compels me to admit that longevity doesn't automatically confer knowledge, wisdom or competence. Sometimes longtime employees are as much a hindrance as an asset.

People with a lot of seniority often adhere to outmoded ideas and are reluctant to accept much-needed change. They are apt to do things a certain way simply because "that's the way we've always done it ... if it ain't broke don't fix it." Think of how many old-timers you've met who want nothing to do with computers. Maybe you're one of them yourself. I've got news for you. Anyone who doesn't try to maximize use of computers in their business in today's world is foolish. Listen to the youngsters in your company who are urging you to make more use of them.

Veteran employees form the backbone of most small businesses. Yet, their attitude often stifles creativity and progress. Maybe they get results, but maybe the results could be even better trying something different. Too often the veterans are more interested in protecting what they have than in striving for more. There's an old saying that when all you have to work with is a hammer, every problem looks like a nail. That's the way many old-timers think. They know only one way of doing things, and are reluctant to try anything else.

This is not to suggest you should look to get rid of all the old folks and replace them with energetic youngsters. For one thing, that could leave you vulnerable to an age-discrimination lawsuit. Besides, most veterans do possess a storehouse of knowledge, wisdom and institutional memory you wouldn't want to dispense with.

The problem is that in too many small companies, seniority has become the only criterion for advancement. You make good old Joe the manager or foreman because he's been there the longest. Maybe it's also because he's slowing down a bit in the field. Sometimes you know deep down that he's not the best person for the job, but you feel obliged to reciprocate loyalty for his many years of service. Besides, you think Joe couldn't handle being supervised by someone half his age.

You should indeed reciprocate loyalty, reward seniority and accommodate veteran employees who may be breaking down physically. But you want to do it in ways that don't alienate the young talent in your organization or hamper your company's ability to progress.

This requires playing to everyone's individual strengths, young and old alike. For instance, some folks are "people persons" and some are not. Many mechanically minded individuals are happiest when they are solving technical problems in the field rather than supervising smart-aleck youngsters or dealing with paperwork. You don't want to put someone like that in charge of managing other people. Yet, that's what is routinely done throughout our economy. In small and big businesses alike, many people get promoted simply because "it's their turn."

Salary Considerations

In many cases, it's all about money. After all, you can't expect to pay your best roofer more than the foreman or supervisor he reports to, can you?

To which I would answer, why not? It may be that the field technician is more valuable and irreplaceable than the person he reports to. If that's the case, it makes more sense to pay him more than to suffer the alternative of weakening yourself in two positions - by taking the roofer away from that which he does best, and promoting him to a supervisory job that he may hate and is ill-equipped to handle.

Keep in mind that professional football coaches and baseball managers typically get paid a lot less than many of their performers. Yet, the good ones still manage to teach and motivate the players. Supervisory jobs have a lot of advantages - desk job, more prestige, steadier hours, less physically demanding - that many people would see as a reasonable trade-off with income.

When you do promote younger employees to supervisory positions, it's important to instruct them to be especially deferential to company veterans. Encourage them to ask their advice frequently (even if they ignore that advice). In some cases, it may be necessary to come up with a reporting structure in which the veteran reports directly to the owner.

More often than not, experienced employees will probably get the nod for promotions by virtue of merit, because experience does have value. The point is, age and experience should not be the sole deciding factor in who gets promoted.

One more point needs to be made about the value of experience. Take another look at the want ads. Most of them advertising for experienced employees ask for "three years" or "five years" of experience. In almost all cases, those are simply arbitrary numbers tossed out without any thought.

The difference between a raw novice and someone with one year of experience in a given trade is vast. Just for the sake of comparison, let's assign an arbitrary number, 100, to represent the difference in "experience points" between zero and one year of experience.

Does this mean the difference between someone with one year of experience and two years of experience would also equal 100? Rarely would that hold true. The so-called learning curve is such that for most jobs, the vast majority of basic knowledge needed to perform the work gets picked up in the first year. The meaningful difference between one and two years of experience might be worth only 25 points rather than 100. The gap keeps declining until you reach a point where there's no meaningful difference. Someone with 25 years of experience in a job has virtually no advantage over someone with 20 years of experience. By that time, talent and drive far overcome any differences in tenure.

So, do yourselves a favor and simply say, "experience a must" or something to that effect when looking for new employees. Otherwise, you risk turning away talented individuals who may have, say, two and a half years of experience while the ad calls for three.

Share This Story

Looking for a reprint of this article?
From high-res PDFs to custom plaques, order your copy today!

Jim Olsztynski is editorial director of Plumbing & Mechanical and editor of Supply House Times magazines. He can be reached at (630) 694-4006 or wrdwzrd@aol.com.

Recommended Content

JOIN TODAY
to unlock your recommendations.

Already have an account? Sign In

  • Roofing Contractor Group Publisher Jill Bloom

    Physics, the Power of Authenticity and You

    In February's Publisher's Note, Jill Bloom describes a...
    Columns
    By: Jill Bloom
  • The Family Food Fare supermarket in Midland, Mich.

    ‘Rooftop Ninja’ Discovered Living on Roof, Inside Grocery Sign

    A bizarre tale out of Midland, Mich.: a woman dubbed the...
    Roofing News
    By: Bryan Gottlieb
  • A before and after heat measurement comparison

    How Hot is Too Hot in the Attic?

    If the ventilation is working, how hot should the attic...
    Sustainable Roofing
    By: Paul Scelsi
You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Report Abusive Comment

Manage My Account
  • eMagazine Subscription
  • Sign Up for the eNewsletter
  • Online Registration
  • Manage My Preferences
  • Subscription Customer Service

More Videos

Sponsored Content

Sponsored Content is a special paid section where industry companies provide high quality, objective, non-commercial content around topics of interest to the Roofing Contractor audience. All Sponsored Content is supplied by the advertising company and any opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and not necessarily reflect the views of Roofing Contractor or its parent company, BNP Media. Interested in participating in our Sponsored Content section? Contact your local rep!

close
  • TAMKO Titan XL Shingles
    Sponsored byTAMKO®

    Built for Business: How Titan XT® Shingles Keep Proving Their Value

  • An overhead view of a residential block
    Sponsored byCBIZ CompuData

    From Spreadsheets to Strategy: How Roofing Companies Can Transform Financial Operations

  • Snow Guard Solutions for Metal Roofs by S-5!
    Sponsored byS-5!

    Safeguard Your Building: How Snow Guards Prevent Costly Roof & Property Damage

Popular Stories

The Home Depot is weighing a bid for GMS. The potential offer would pit the retail giant against QXO Inc.

UPDATE: Home Depot Pushes QXO Out of GMS Pursuit

Brad Jacobs, chairman and CEO of QXO, offers $5 billion to acquire GMS, a major distributor of gypsum and interior building products.

QXO Sets Its Sights on GMS in $5 Billion Offer

Undocumented workers make up 36% of the U.S. roofing workforce, leaving contractors and workers alike especially vulnerable.

Roofing is Left Exposed by Trump’s Deportation Flip-Flop

Roofing Contractor Webinar

Events

December 3, 2025

The Premier Roofing Conference: Best of Success

Join roofing professionals from across the nation at the 2025 Best of Success conference, the ultimate destination for roofing professionals seeking the latest industry insights and networking opportunities. Pick up strategies for critical challenges like workforce shortage with innovative solutions, explore the latest advancements in roofing technology and sustainable practices, and gain valuable insights from industry leaders on navigating the evolving roofing landscape.

View All Submit An Event

Related Articles

  • Smart Business: The Bigger They Are, the Harder They Fall

    See More
  • Smart Business- Master the Art of Listening

    See More
  • Smart Business: Managing By the Open Book

    See More

Related Products

See More Products
  • roofingpic.jpg

    Managing the Profitable Construction Business: The Contractor's Guide to Success and Survival Strategies

  • business.png

    How to Succeed With Your Own Construction Business

See More Products
×

Be in the forefront of the roofing industry!

Join thousands of professionals today. Shouldn’t you know what they know?

JOIN NOW!
  • RESOURCES
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
    • Directories
    • Store
    • Want More
  • SIGN UP TODAY
    • Create Account
    • eMagazine
    • eNewsletter
    • Customer Service
    • Manage Preferences
  • SERVICES
    • Marketing Services
    • Reprints
    • Market Research
    • List Rental
    • Survey/Respondent Access
  • STAY CONNECTED
    • LinkedIn
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • YouTube
    • X
  • PRIVACY
    • PRIVACY POLICY
    • TERMS & CONDITIONS
    • DO NOT SELL MY PERSONAL INFORMATION
    • PRIVACY REQUEST
    • ACCESSIBILITY

Copyright ©2025. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing