search
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube instagram Spotify Podcasts Apple Podcasts Spotify Podcasts Apple Podcasts
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
  • NEWS
  • TOPICS
    • Cool Roofing
    • Event News
    • Latinos in Roofing
    • Low Slope
    • Legal
    • Metal
    • Project Profiles
    • Roofing Supply Pro
    • Roofing Safety
    • Steep Slope
    • Sustainable Roofing
    • Technology
  • EXCLUSIVES
    • Best of Success
    • Contractor Profile
    • IRE Show
    • Roofing Contractor of the Year
      • Enter Roofing Contractor of the Year
    • Top 100
      • Enter the Top 100
    • Young Guns
    • State of the Industry
    • Century Club
  • MULTIMEDIA
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
    • Interactive Spotlights
    • Roofing Quizzes
    • IRE Videos
    • Webinars
    • Photo Galleries
  • PRODUCTS
    • New Products
    • Featured Products
  • COLUMNS
    • Editor's Note
    • Exit Planning
    • Legally Speaking
    • Safety Advice
    • Technical Details
    • Guest Column
  • EVENTS
    • International Roofing Expo
    • Webinars
    • Best of Success Conference
    • Industry Events
  • DIRECTORY
    • Associations
    • Distributors
    • Manufacturer/Supplier
    • Business Services
    • Get Listed
  • MORE
    • Roofing Contractor eNews
    • RC Store
    • Roofing Supply Pro
    • Custom Content & Marketing Services
    • Market Research
    • Sponsor Insights
    • Company Spotlights
    • Classifieds
      • Auctions
      • Business For Sale
      • Business Opportunities
      • Equipment For Sale
      • Positions Available
      • Products
      • Safety
      • Software
      • Services
      • Training
    • Contact Us
  • EMAGAZINE
    • eMagazine
    • Advertise
      • Media Kit
      • Editorial Calendar
      • Contact
    • Archive Issues
  • SIGN UP!
Columns

There is No Magic Bonus Plan

By Monroe Porter
October 1, 2004
If you have been reading my column for a while, you have read my comments on bonuses. Contrary to what you might think, I am not totally opposed to them. However, for every good bonus system I encounter; I see 100 that ultimately must be dismantled.

Rewarding people with performance pay is a simple theory but not so easy to practice. Employee compensation is a complex subject. Company culture, regional differences, trade practices and many other factors will impact what is the best compensation approach for your company.

Practice good management, not magic formulas.

The best performance system is to pay people well and hold them accountable. One of the greatest advantages of any incentive program is that the nature of giving incentives forces you to measure performance. You must know what each person is doing in order to award the incentive. Such measurement is the first step of good management. So why not just practice good management? This means to hold people accountable, pay the people well who do well and fire the ones that don't.

They call them employees, not competitors.

As crazy as employees can make us, employees are employees, not owners. They do not own a business but rather have chosen to work for someone else. So no matter how much you pay them per piece, a commission or whatever else, they are employees, not competitors.

Don't mess with their pay.

Employees will forgive you for almost anything but messing around with their paycheck. The number one reason most incentive programs fail is that they are not clearly thought out and all scenarios aren't taken into account. Once you start a system, it can be very difficult to stop. So don't start a program until you have clearly planned ahead for various circumstances, such as a bad economy, a mature workforce, a weather situation, the impact of the best employees receiving the most difficult jobs, etc. Any incentive system must be fair to both the company and employee. It also should be simple so that employees clearly understand it. Ultimately, wages are determined by supply and demand, so if you do not pay a livable wage, your employees can go somewhere else. Remember, all systems must also be legal and comply with wage and hour laws.

Production Bonus Pitfalls

It is very difficult to create a field production bonus that is fair. Most contractors assign their best people the most complex and difficult jobs. The most skilled field person normally starts with a more difficult incentive target. What happens when your best field person is killing him or herself on a tough job and receives no bonus, yet your newest employee is sliding through job production on an easy job and receives a hefty check?

Suppose times are tough economically and jobs are quoted with less time and margin? What if incentives improve productivity, as production rates drop, estimates are recalculated with lower rates and the incentives disappear? Ever had it rain or snow in your area? Have you ever had an incorrect quote or had a poorly run job that is out of your control? Any of these scenarios can create an unmotivated workforce when you need his or her best performance.

Profit Sharing-Retirement Programs

Such programs are an employee benefit designed to attract and keep quality employees. Rarely will they actually improve day-to-day productivity. However, just like hospitalization, paid holidays, vacation, etc., profit sharing can be a valuable employment tool.

Discretionary vs. Formula Bonuses

Discretionary bonuses are just that-discretionary. They are awarded at management's will. The advantage of such a system is that you can make concessions for high achievers who fall outside of the normal formula. The disadvantage is that they are discretionary and subject to employee perceptions. Discretionary bonuses require ongoing feedback throughout the year detailing where the company stands. Formula bonuses are based on a set formula. On paper they seem like good ideas but rarely can they be designed where they are totally fair.

Christmas and Year-end Bonus

Arbitrary bonuses that are dispersed at year end and near the holidays are perceived as gifts and are more likely deferred compensation, not production bonuses. Never distribute performance-oriented bonuses near the year-end holiday season.

Also, there is a family factor at work here. If you have given a holiday bonus for years and suddenly stop, you become the bad guy. Family gifts, buying practices, etc., may be established around this tradition. A little spouse "pillow talk" can wipe out the memory of even the best thought out company justification as to why no bonuses will be awarded.

Net Profit Bonuses

In theory, basing bonuses on net profits makes sense. If there's no profit, there's no bonus. However, the realities of such a system are a little different. Do you really want your employees determining when you should buy company vehicles or better yet what kind of vehicle you drive? Remember, bonus programs are not a total partnership deal. If something goes wrong at the company, they come to get your house, not the employees'. Profit is your return for the risk you take.

OK, before start sending me dozens of e-mails about how great your system works, I concede there are good systems out there. But each and every company is different. What will work for one company may not work for another. The purpose of this article is merely to make you stop and think through something, prior to just doing it. If you institute a bonus system that seems like a "no brainer," well, it probably is. No long-range brain power was used when you put it together.

Share This Story

Looking for a reprint of this article?
From high-res PDFs to custom plaques, order your copy today!

Monroeporter
Monroe Porter is the president of PROOF Management Consultants. He can be reached at 804-267-1688.

Recommended Content

JOIN TODAY
to unlock your recommendations.

Already have an account? Sign In

  • Roofing Contractor Group Publisher Jill Bloom

    Physics, the Power of Authenticity and You

    In February's Publisher's Note, Jill Bloom describes a...
    Editor's Note
    By: Jill Bloom
  • The Family Food Fare supermarket in Midland, Mich.

    ‘Rooftop Ninja’ Discovered Living on Roof, Inside Grocery Sign

    A bizarre tale out of Midland, Mich.: a woman dubbed the...
    Roofing News
    By: Bryan Gottlieb
  • A before and after heat measurement comparison

    How Hot is Too Hot in the Attic?

    If the ventilation is working, how hot should the attic...
    Steep Slope Roofing
    By: Paul Scelsi
You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Report Abusive Comment

Subscribe For Free!
  • eMagazine Subscription
  • Sign Up for the eNewsletter
  • Online Registration
  • Manage My Preferences
  • Subscription Customer Service

More Videos

Sponsored Content

Sponsored Content is a special paid section where industry companies provide high quality, objective, non-commercial content around topics of interest to the Roofing Contractor audience. All Sponsored Content is supplied by the advertising company and any opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and not necessarily reflect the views of Roofing Contractor or its parent company, BNP Media. Interested in participating in our Sponsored Content section? Contact your local rep!

close
  • Snow Guard Solutions for Metal Roofs by S-5!
    Sponsored byS-5!

    Safeguard Your Building: How Snow Guards Prevent Costly Roof & Property Damage

  • A hand holding a wooden block that reads 'EVOLVE'
    Sponsored byWatercress Financial

    Embracing Change: A New Era for the Roofing Industry

Popular Stories

QXO closed its acquisition of Beacon Building Supply on April 29, 2025.

QXO Closes Beacon Acquisition, Rebrands Immediately; Jacobs to Ring NYSE Bell

New executive orders signed by President Trump will likely further constrict an already tight labor market for the construction industry.

New Executive Orders Will Further Squeeze Labor Force

President Trump’s trade war is causing real harm to the construction sector, including roofing contractors.

Trade War Fallout: Contractors Are Delaying Projects and Cutting Crews

Roofing Contractor Webinar

Events

May 22, 2025

Remote Teams 101: The New Way to Hire

Our industry experts will guide you through what remote hiring and outsourcing should look like, how it can help you grow, and why it’s easier (and less scary) than you might think. If you want to save time, find great talent, and grow your business, this is one session you don’t want to miss!

December 3, 2025

The Premier Roofing Conference: Best of Success

Join roofing professionals from across the nation at the 2025 Best of Success conference, the ultimate destination for roofing professionals seeking the latest industry insights and networking opportunities. Pick up strategies for critical challenges like workforce shortage with innovative solutions, explore the latest advancements in roofing technology and sustainable practices, and gain valuable insights from industry leaders on navigating the evolving roofing landscape.

View All Submit An Event

Related Articles

  • Measuring Up

    Sales Compensation: Bonuses, Commissions and Other Magic Formulas

    See More
  • high

    Dealing With a Family Succession Plan

    See More
  • Make Sure No One Has Their Hand in Your Cookie Jar

    See More
×

Be in the forefront of the roofing industry!

Join thousands of professionals today. Shouldn’t you know what they know?

JOIN NOW!
  • RESOURCES
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
    • Directories
    • Store
    • Want More
  • SIGN UP TODAY
    • Create Account
    • eMagazine
    • eNewsletter
    • Customer Service
    • Manage Preferences
  • SERVICES
    • Marketing Services
    • Reprints
    • Market Research
    • List Rental
    • Survey/Respondent Access
  • STAY CONNECTED
    • LinkedIn
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • YouTube
    • X
  • PRIVACY
    • PRIVACY POLICY
    • TERMS & CONDITIONS
    • DO NOT SELL MY PERSONAL INFORMATION
    • PRIVACY REQUEST
    • ACCESSIBILITY

Copyright ©2025. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing