This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies. Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more.
This Website Uses Cookies
By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to our cookie policy. Learn More
This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies. Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more.
Roofing Contractor logo
search
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
Roofing Contractor logo
  • Home
  • Magazine
    • Current Issue
    • Digital Issue
    • Archives
  • Topics
    • Cool Roofing
    • Low Slope
    • Metal
    • News
    • Products
    • Product of the Month
    • Project Profiles
    • Safety
    • Steep Slope
    • Sustainability
    • Trade Shows
    • Technology
  • Exclusives
    • Best of Success
    • Contractor Profile
    • IRE Show Daily
    • Made in the USA
    • Roofing Contractor of the Year
      • Enter Roofing Contractor of the Year
    • Top 100
      • Enter the Top 100
    • Young Guns
    • Web Exclusives
    • Editor's Choice
    • State of the Industry
    • Century Club
  • Columns
    • Editor's Note
    • Measuring Up
    • Legally Speaking
    • Safety Advice
    • Technical Details
    • Guest Column
    • High-Tech Roofing
    • Sustainable Roofing
    • Marketing Makeover
    • Leadership Selling
  • Blog
    • Damato of the Day
  • Multimedia
    • Roofing Quiz
    • Videos
    • IRE 2019 Videos
    • Webinars
    • Photo Galleries
    • Interactive Spotlights
  • More
    • Classified Ads
    • Roofing Contractor eNews
    • RC Store
    • Directory: Roofing Resource
    • Market Research
    • Custom Content & Marketing Services
    • Sponsor Insights
  • Events
    • International Roofing Expo
    • Industry Events
    • Webinars
    • Best of Success Conference
  • Contact
    • Advertise
  • Directory
    • Associations
    • Distributors
    • Manufacturer/Supplier
    • Get Listed
    • Business Services
  • Subscribe
    • Print & Digital Edition Subscriptions
    • Sign Up for the eNewsletter
    • Online Registration
    • Subscription Customer Service
Home » Legally Speaking: Presentation of Damages Caused by Disruption
Columns

Legally Speaking: Presentation of Damages Caused by Disruption

January 30, 2002
Reprints
No Comments
Almost every contractor has experienced that problem project, the one in which just about everything goes badly. Causes for these problem projects range from excessive numbers of changes, unforeseen conditions, late delivery of essential materials or equipment, etc., and the escalation of labor costs. If the contractor cannot resolve this situation equitably with the owner, the contractor must prepare and file a claim for delay and disruption.

However, in many situations there is not a single factor causing delay and disruption, but many. For instance, consider a project in which there are many changes to the work and a long delay. Experience shows that the real impact on labor is far more than the simple sum of the individual changes. For a single change order, the contractor can usually measure the lost time due to the change order process, reassign his manpower accordingly, and take meaningful steps in the field to mitigate losses. When numerous changes are involved impacting several parts of the project, the ability of the contractor to take meaningful steps is jeopardized. Large disruptions in the flow of work result in inefficiencies and lost productivity from factors such as reassignment of labor, overtime, dilution of supervision, etc.

Given such a complicated situation, the contractor will often file a claim normally referred to as a cumulative impact claim. In order to be successful on this type of claim action, contractors must recognize the process for measuring damages and how such a claim must be presented. Among the more important factors to consider are:

Contractors must demonstrate that a fundamental change in the character of the work had changed and this change was not foreseeable. A case where a cumulative impact claim was successful involved Ingalls Shipbuilding. There was a 58 percent increase in the contract price and a four-year increase in contract time; however, even in this case, the claimant had to demonstrate the fundamental change in the work, not just a statement of percentages of increase.

Cumulative impacts need not be traced to specific causes of increased performance costs, but, can arise from changes or conditions which, when viewed retrospectively, were so numerous and had such effect on performance that there is a separately compensable impact claim.

The elements of proof for a cumulative impact claim are:

  • A significantly large number of change or disruptive events.

  • The changes or events have impact on productivity (performance time and efficiency).

  • The impact flows from the synergy of the number and scope of changes,

  • The contractor was unable at the time of pricing of each change or event or directive to foresee the ripple-type effect of the multiplicity of change and events.

  • The contractor did not knowingly waive the right to assert cumulative impact claims when negotiating changes.

Contractors must keep in mind that a major focus of their claim must be on “causation.” Claims are routinely denied because there were insufficient numbers of changes, contractor-caused concurrent delays or disruptions, and a general absence of evidence of causation and impact. While the courts have expressed that proving causation in the cumulative impact claim is difficult “because the concept of cumulative impact is, in itself, somewhat amorphous,” the contractor must still present the court with a reasonable explanation of how the complex nature of changes caused the claimed cost overruns.

Contractors facing claims for disruption, particularly those involving a cumulative impact claim, must be mindful that they must maintain sufficient records to demonstrate causation. Little things can mean a lot. Simply intensifying their efforts to enter onto daily time sheets the foreseen and unforeseen impacts and changes can position a contractor for future success.

Did you enjoy this article? Click here to subscribe to Roofing Contractor Magazine.

Related Articles

Legally Speaking: Disruptive Impacts to the Construction Project

Legally Speaking: Manage Your Legal Exposure by Reviewing Overtime Standards

You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Report Abusive Comment

Subscribe For Free!
  • Print & Digital Edition Subscriptions
  • Sign Up for the eNewsletter
  • Online Registration
  • Subscription Customer Service

More Videos

Popular Stories

operation-freelancer-viii

16 Unlicensed Florida Contractors Arrested in ‘Operation Freelancer VIII’

ABC logo

ABC Supply Launches myABCsupply to Help Roofing Contractors Manage Business on the Go

ice-river-roofers-save-woman

Roofers Rescue Woman from Drowning in Icy River

Tesla-solar-glass-roof-v3

Tesla Hiring Roofers for Solarglass Roof Installations

gavel-law

New York Signs Laws to Protect Homeowners Against ‘Storm Chasers’

roofing quiz
Roofing Resource

Roofing Contractor Magazine

Roofing Contractor Cover 2019 November

2019 November

The November issue features our Residential and Commercial Contractors of the Year for 2019! Check out our interviews with these outstanding contractors, including video from Best of Success.
View More Create Account
  • Resources
    • Construction Group
    • Partners
    • List Rental
    • Subscribe
    • Privacy Policy
    • Survey And Sample
  • Videos
  • Want More
    • Connect
  • Advertise

Copyright ©2019. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing