The building is steeped in character but had been missing numerous roof shingles since the winter of 1999.

Late in the 1890s, William E. Sutherland settled Orcas Island and later built the Orcas Island Hotel. Through the years, it has changed hands more than a few times, but in June of 1998, the Tidwells discovered that the hotel was for sale. They jumped at the chance. “Living on Orcas Island is like stepping back in time,” smiled Doug Tidwell. “We love raising our children here and we love living here. Most of all we have enjoyed fixing up and managing the hotel. It is rich in history and architecture and really sets the tone for visitors to the island.